In order of predicted finish...
1. Chicago White Sox
Strength - Pitching
They are solid 1-4 in the rotation led by veteran strike-thrower Mark Buehrle. While Jake Peavy is a health risk, he is one of the most competitive pitchers in baseball, so he won't shut it down without a fight. John Danks and Gavin Floyd are not famous names, but they deliver consistent performances. Bobby Jenks can make it interesting, but he's saved 29+ games in each of the last four seasons. If J.J. Putz is healthy, he will form the best middle relief bridge in the game alongside lefty Matt Thornton.
Weakness - Pop
In this rare case, they will look back on their weakness as a strength. I may not be right about much, but I screamed from the hills about the stupidity of trading Aaron Rowand for Jim Thome in the offseason after the ChiSox won the World Series with a team built on speed on defense. In the last few years, they have been mired in mediocrity trying to make mismatched parts fit with an aggressive manager and old, slugging position players. Now that Thome and Jermaine Dye are gone, Ozzie Guillen can recreate the speed and defense identity around Juan Pierre, Alex Rios, Gordon Beckham and others.
2. Minnesota Twins
Strength - M&M's
When you have a foundation like Joe Mauer and Justin Morneau, it makes a GM's life a lot easier. The Twins are able to make smart, value buys each year like Orlando Hudson and Jim Thome because they have those two rocks in place. However, they lost Joe Nathan, who was that third consistent force in the franchise.
Weakness - Bullpen
I love their starting rotation. While their biggest name is the infamous Carl Pavano, Scott Baker and Nick Blackburn are future stars plus Francisco Liriano can still be salvaged. However, without Nathan, the bullpen is out of order. Everyone slides up a spot, which makes the bullpen weaker on the whole not just in the 9th inning. They will work it out by the end of the season, but they should blow enough games late to get pipped for the division by the Sox.
3. Detroit Tigers
Strength - Offseason
Despite potential financial worries around the mass exodus of the Detroit population and thus their fanbase, GM Dave Dombrowski put them in a position to win this season. They traded Curtis Granderson for CF Austin Jackson, who will probably struggle in his first year in the bigs. However, they replaced Granderson's bat with Johnny Damon. And, they filled holes in their pitching staff with flamethrower Max Scherzer, lefty Phil Coke and closer Jose "Pops" Valverde. Joel Zumaya looks like his old self (101 MPH!) in spring training, so he could be the biggest addition.
Weakness - Now or Later
Damon, Miguel Cabrera, Justin Verlander, Carlos Guillen and Magglio Ordonez are ready to win right now. Jackson, Rick Porcello and Scherzer are moves to win in the future. They should be in the division race by the trade deadline when Dombrowski will have to decide if the plan is to win now or later.
4. Kansas City Royals
Strength - Three-Game Series
The Royals illustrate perfectly the difference between the two leagues. Kansas City is awful, but they could be a pain in the ass in a three-game series. If you have the rough luck to draw Zack Greinke, Gil Meche and Luke Hochevar, you are not leaving town with a sweep. Plus, they have closer Joakim Soria, who will make 8-inning leads count.
Weakness - Confusion
What is the plan? They signed Jason Kendall, who has to be the worst hitter in baseball, to a big money contract. They made aggressive moves to reel in Rick Ankiel (.231 with 99 Ks in '09) and Scott Podsednik (34 years old). They are acting like a veteran team that just needs a couple extra pieces to put them over the top. They should be using those at-bats on young players because they don't have any top position talents at the big league level.
5. Cleveland Indians
Strength - Where have all the Indians gone?
No CC Sabathia, no Cliff Lee, no Victor Martinez. They are built around Grady Sizemore (terribly overrated!), Jhonny Peralta (terrible spelling) and Shin-Soo Choo (not terrible, I like him). Fausto Carmona has had a big spring training, so maybe he will carry the rotation.
Weakness - Who are these guys?
Who is their closer? Chris Perez...Tony Sipp...never heard of 'em. I know their organization well enough to know that they have a plan, but the plan is clearly NOT to win this season. Mitch Talbot and Carlos Carrasco are listed as rotation candidates. It's like a who's NOT who of baseball players.
Ranking the Division's Best
Best Lineup
1. Twins - People forget that they didn't have Morneau for the playoffs.
2. Tigers - Cabrera is the best pure hitter in the A.L..
3. White Sox - If Carlos Quentin from '08 returns, they'll be special.
4. Indians - Young talents Matt LaPorta, Trevor Crowe and Michael Brantley inject some life.
5. Royals - I like Billy Butler.
Best Rotation
1. White Sox - Peavy is the key...
2. Twins - Can C-Pav do it now that he has a contract?
3. Tigers - Verlander and Porcello are a good place to start.
4. Royals - Greinke...
5. Indians - Carmona needs to pull a Cliff Lee like renaissance.
Best Bullpen
1. White Sox - Thornton is a stud...
2. Tigers - Zumaya is a stud...
3. Royals - Soria is a stud...
4. Twins - Rauch is NOT a stud...
5. Indians - Ricky Vaughn is a stud...
Best Manager
1. Tigers - Pack-a-day Jim Leyland is old school.
2. Twins - Ron Gardenhire puts them in position every season.
3. White Sox - Ozzie Guillen's ego doesn't fit in the baseball culture.
4. Indians - Manny Acta should be given a long leash with this roster.
5. Royals - Trey Hillman is not long for this job.
Fantasy Sleepers
1. Shin-Soo Choo, OF, Indians - .300/20/20 last year and he's improving.
2. Gordon Beckham, 2B, White Sox - Good as a rookie, star as a sophomore...
3. Francisco Liriano, SP, Twins - All the reports are good.
4. Fausto Carmona, SP, Indians - The ceiling is still high.
5. Joel Zumaya, RP, Tigers - Strikeouts...
Fantasy owners should ride the train...the Choo Choo train.
